Found in the Untended Graves, inside the Flameless Shrine. They can be found on a body lying beyond an illusory wall located where Irina normally resides in Firelink Shrine. The existence of this wall is hinted by the shorter length that corridor has, if compared to its normal shrine version counterpart.
- Though grateful for such a precious gift, the Fire Keeper will show herself reluctant of letting the Ashen One have this as one of their options and will repeatedly ask them to end her life and take the eyes from her body. If the player complies to her plead, she will reappear in the shrine the next time they visit it and state that as a fire keeper, she cannot be permanently killed. The player may give her the eyes again if they choose to do so.
- If the player talks to Ludleth of Courland with the eyes in their inventory, he will discourage from giving them to the Fire Keeper, remarking that: "These eyes might reveal to the eyeless Firekeeper. Scenes of betrayal, things never intended for her ken, visions of... this age's end..."